Keeping Pitchers. WHIR!!!

[chargerss24]

I'm in a 12-team 6x6 roto (standard stat + holds/OBP) league. I have eight pitchers and get to keep only 5. Here they are:

J. Santana
C. Hamels
J. Peavy
D. Price
Z. Greinke
K. Slowey
R. Dempster
M. Pelfrey

Which five you keep? Thanks for your help in advance! WHIR!

[San D]

J. Santana
C. Hamels
J. Peavy
D. Price
Z. Greinke

[bucksox]

Santana
Hamels
Peavy
Greinke
Price(if no minors)


I guess you can't really pass up hanging on to Price here. But I don't know what he will give you this year. It depends on if they let him loose or not.

[sdieckhaus]

I hate to be redundant, but I guess it helps to solidify what you do:

J. Santana
C. Hamels
J. Peavy
D. Price
Z. Greinke

[The_Show]

Pretty much agree with everyone else:

J. Santana
C. Hamels
J. Peavy
D. Price
Z. Greinke

[SecretAgentMan]

Slowey and Pelfrey are not even in consideration imo. Basically this is a Dempster vs. Price question. Unknown rookie hype vs. historical stiff who suddenly got his act together. Tough call, but I would err on the side of Price here. Never liked Dempster.

[chargerss24]

Considering that I currently have Santana, Peavy, Price, Hamels and Greinke in my active lineup, it sounds like an unanimous decision! Thanks for the input!

[Dan Charette]

I'm in a 12-team 6x6 roto (standard stat + holds/OBP) league. I have eight pitchers and get to keep only 5. Here they are:

J. Santana
C. Hamels
J. Peavy
D. Price
Z. Greinke
K. Slowey
R. Dempster
M. Pelfrey

Which five you keep? Thanks for your help in advance! WHIR!

That is a nice group of pitchers.