Is this fair?

[abrage22]

don't worry about rosters or anything, but i got a trade and i just want you to tell me whos getting the better deal, and by how much.

Team A gets Gallardo and J Bruce

Team B gets M Ramirez

Its a dynasty league 12 team 5x5.

thanks you

[Grounded Polo]

I'd go with Bruce and Gallardo in a dynasty. Bruce can be a hitter with value not too far below Ramirez and Gallardo was spectacular in 2007. Basically, there's a safe chance that combined, they will have pretty equal value to Manny but since they're also young, there's also a pretty good chance they could surpass Manny.

[ayebatter]

I'd go with Bruce and Gallardo in a dynasty. Bruce can be a hitter with value not too far below Ramirez and Gallardo was spectacular in 2007. Basically, there's a safe chance that combined, they will have pretty equal value to Manny but since they're also young, there's also a pretty good chance they could surpass Manny.

Agree with GP

[MadDog36]

Its definitely a fair trade of now vs. later.

[RunReyesRun]

Yep. If you see your team as a serious contender this yr, stick with Manny.

If not, jump all over this trade

[San D]

I'd prefer the Gallardo/Bruce side. If someone was to base the trade off of 2008 stats, then Manny is the better side. But, for all the reasons stated in the above post, the Gallardo/Bruce side is better.

[raiders_umpire]

I'd go with Bruce and Gallardo in a dynasty. Bruce can be a hitter with value not too far below Ramirez and Gallardo was spectacular in 2007. Basically, there's a safe chance that combined, they will have pretty equal value to Manny but since they're also young, there's also a pretty good chance they could surpass Manny.

I agree with the crazy Mets fan.

[MaudDib]

I'd go with Bruce and Gallardo in a dynasty. Bruce can be a hitter with value not too far below Ramirez and Gallardo was spectacular in 2007. Basically, there's a safe chance that combined, they will have pretty equal value to Manny but since they're also young, there's also a pretty good chance they could surpass Manny.

I agree with the crazy Mets fan.

But good trade. Nothing wrong with either side.

[WBC]

Id go with Gallardo Bruce in a dynasty any day of the week.!!!!

viewtopic.php?t=364441