TRADE AROD<> HANLEY. KEEP 8???

[GiantsFan14]

mcab
utley
hanley
braun
beltran
holliday
teixeira
sabathia

i'd make the deal and keep those 8.

imo, hanley>a-rod and holliday>rollins (even with the move to oakland)

[AquaMan2342]

mcab
utley
hanley
braun
beltran
holliday
teixeira
sabathia

i'd make the deal and keep those 8.

imo, hanley>a-rod and holliday>rollins (even with the move to oakland)

I know he would have Hanley at SS, but Rollins at SS is still more valuable than Oakland Holliday in the OF in my opinion.

[nerachnia]

I think holliday will have a bit of a drop in Oakland...about 10% or so .....but I might still do the trade because i thik Arod is going to start to drop too. If for some reason they get TEix on the yankees then everything i just said about arod is null and void.

[The Artful Dodger]

This trade obviously won't mean any dropoff in quality at all. I like Hanley/Holliday value-wise and on production personally. I'm not quite buying into the possibility of Holliday's production dropping off steeply even if it should a bit. The only problem you could run into is that you'll be without a 3B past '09 at least.