Fielder & Garza for Youk & Tulo. No Brainer?

[GHirsch516]

I was just made an offer which im thinking is a possible no brainer but wanted to bounce it off some of you. Ive been offered Fielder and Garza for Youk and Tulo. Ja?? I wasnt even going to keep Tulo and probably wont keep Garza either. I'd like to get some feedback on this. Thanks!

This is a CBS 8 man keeper league. My keepers are as follows:

R. Howard
K. Youk
A. Dunn
B. Phillips
R. Ludwick

T. Lincecum
F. Liriano
R. Harden

I have Price on my minor roster too.

[oddmanout7]

So you are basically dealing Youk for Fielder. Good deal for you.

[ensanimal]

The only advantage Youk would have is that he is 3B eligible, but you have to take Fielder.

I think you should do decent in Hr's with Prince, Howard and Dunn.

[GHirsch516]

I really like Youk and think he will put up consistent numbers but I felt the same way about Fielder. Im not sure what the sudden rush is to dump this guy. I looked in this forum today and there were about 3 other threads regarding trying to move him. He didnt have a good 1st half and really didnt get it in gear until later in the 2nd but hes still has alot of room to grow. I think is potential upside is alot better than Youks. Anyway with all this negativity about Fielder makes him a good candidate to buy low on right now. Thats just mho..

[Guzman24]

I like the Garza/Fielder side of the deal. I think Fielder will have better numbers than Youk next year. Garza and Tulo are a bit of a wash.

[tyler2]

I really like Youk and think he will put up consistent numbers but I felt the same way about Fielder. Im not sure what the sudden rush is to dump this guy. I looked in this forum today and there were about 3 other threads regarding trying to move him. He didnt have a good 1st half and really didnt get it in gear until later in the 2nd but hes still has alot of room to grow. I think is potential upside is alot better than Youks. Anyway with all this negativity about Fielder makes him a good candidate to buy low on right now. Thats just mho..

I concur.

[jlm53089]

I would take Garza and Fielder.
But I would consider Garza over LIriano.
But I am not sure if you would want that, the way Garza pitched last year he has shown he has the stuff.
Liriano is an injury risk and struggled early on before he got everything together.
Just an opinion hope it helps