Help with Pujols and Holliday

[Yoda]

Thanks for the advice. On the Verlander note, I have to keep a 3rd pitcher to keep a 5th hitter. At this point, I'm just taking a chance on him.

My last question is: What is Holliday's true value? Meaning, what young stud would I take heads up for him and be happy?

Thanks again!

Depends on need. I would hang onto him.

[MaudDib]

I would keep Pujols for sure, but I would shop Holliday. See what you can get for him, if you can get a young stud for him I'd pull the trigger.

exactly

If he was going to have surgery he would have done it right after the season. Right now he would just be exteding his DL time and I don't think he wants to do that. Especially after a season where the showed more than most people thought they would and hopefully can build on that to get in the playoffs again.

[tyler2]

Players I would trade Holliday straight up for (ignoring needs, assuming dynasty and 5x5): Hanley, A-Rod, Reyes, Utley, M. Cab., Braun, Sizemore, Berkman, Hamilton, Kinsler, Santana, Teixeira, Morneau, Peavy, Lincecum, Rollins, Longoria, Sabathia, Webb, Pedroia, Fielder, BJ Upton, Markakis. I'd consider Soriano, Beltran, Carlos Lee, Bay, Hamels, Crawford, Quentin, and Kemp. Might be leaving others out.