Money League:Pick 7 Keepers

[Philliebuster]

Cbs.sportsline keeper league, need to pick 7 to build from in 2007, h2h points league, any 5 pitchers start. Hitters score more points than pitchers at a ratio of approximately 3:2.

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins
SS-Carlos Guillen
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

[Halo Homers]

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins - I don't like him if he is traded
SS-Carlos Guillen - Loses SS eligibilty. Don't like him at 3b
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn So hot and cold, not the greatest H to H guy. Could be talked into Vmart instead.
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod - He going to probably end up with Mets or Angels, so he will get a lot of opportunties again . K Rod A nice H to H guy.
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

[abrage22]

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins
SS-Carlos Guillen
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

[oddmanout7]

1-Fielder
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
P-Johan
P-Peavy


I think the last 2 spots are between Alexei, Dunn and KRod. People are really high on Alexei, I am not one of them, but still with SS being so shallow, I think you have to keep him and hope for the best. the last spot, a top 3 closer or 40HR? I think I would go with KRod.

[kab21]

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins
SS-Carlos Guillen
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

I don't like Alexei and if VMart sounds really healthy I might switch this to him. But it's too early to know that.

[HOOTIE]

Lot of love for KRod, who could just as easily have 30 saves this year.

VMart
Fielder
Alexei
Beltran
Dunn
Santana
Peavy

[SecretAgentMan]

Cbs.sportsline keeper league, need to pick 7 to build from in 2007, h2h points league, any 5 pitchers start. Hitters score more points than pitchers at a ratio of approximately 3:2.

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins
SS-Carlos Guillen
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

I take the chance Atkins is not dealt before the season starts. If Dunn posts more points than Krod in your league, I would switch to him.

[fast dogs]

I believe Oddmanout has it right, especially if you use a MI in your settings. I'd prefer 3/7 keeper spots not be OF if I can help it

[wkelly91]

C-Vmart
1-Fielder
2-Alexi Ramirez
3-Atkins
SS-Carlos Guillen
OF-Beltran
OF-Bay
OF-Dunn
B-N. Cruz
P-Johan
P-Peavy
P-Verlander
P-Krod
P-Scherzer
P-Lidge

[Philliebuster]

Thanks for the responses, based on the responses i'm probably leaning....

Vmart
Beltran
Bay
Fielder
Johan
Peavy
Krod

The decision is between these for the last 2 spots:
Krod - I'm a Mets fan, if he goes to the Metro's I think I'll have to hang onto him. But the members in this league highly undervalue relievers, I might be able to get Krod sooner in the draft.
Alexi - I am very intrigued with Alexi, even more if he starts at SS next year. But depending on the preseason hype, he may be able to be had a little later in the draft. For the reasons above I could switch Alexi out with Krod.
Vmart - I think that his last season was a fluke. I think i'd have the hardest time recouping him in the draft as he would probably be picked pretty early.
Dunn - I forgot to add that the league deducts for strikeouts, Dunn has barely broke 400 points the last 4 year.

Dark Horses???:
I think both these guys are going to have nice seasons in 09, but I cant justify keepin one...or can I....I could probably get the back in the draft a bit later/easier though....
Scherzer
Verlander