Which one do I keep out of these 10

[Chiefscards]

This is a 20 team H2H keeper. My current keepers are-

M. Cabrera
J. Bay
J. Hamilton
N. McLouth
C. Maybin
R. Nolasco
J. Duchscherer
B. Lidge

We use the MI position as well as 2b and SS. Any of these keeper material? Or should I look to make a couple trades in the off season?

M Jacobs, T Helton, A Pettitte, T Hudson, C Cordero, J Queto, T Teagarden, A Cabrera, B Wood, E Bonifacio

[Yoda]

Looks like Cueto and Hudson are your best bets unless you want to roll the dice with Wood.

[abrage22]

I'd go with Cueto

[bigken117]

Queto and Teagraden.


I would consider Cueto over Nolasco...

And though I'm not a fan of the catcher position scarcity theorem, in a 20 team league, gambling on Teagarden could be huge.

[AquaMan2342]

Queto and Teagraden.


I would consider Cueto over Nolasco...

And though I'm not a fan of the catcher position scarcity theorem, in a 20 team league, gambling on Teagarden could be huge.

This is definitely how I feel. None of the others outside of Cueto are really that productive. Why not take a risk with Teagarden?

[San D]

Cueto pretty easily out of those 10.

[AquaMan2342]

Let me rephrase what I said.

Take out Duchscherer and put in Cueto/Teagarden.

[ensanimal]

Teagarden for me. Big time reward possibly for a 20 team league.

I wold look at making some 2 for 1 trades, especially with some of your pitchers. Look at packaging Duch and Nolasco (2 guys I don't trust) for an upgrade SP, and then keep Cueto as well.