I'd stick with Cabrera. Sure, there are loads of mashing dudes at 1B, but Cabby's special. Since it's a keeper league, I'd go with the young buck. He's about 5 years younger than Utley, and might not have even reached his full potential yet. And as good as his numbers were this year for Detroit, they'll get better next season. He had to adjust to a new league and a new position at the same time, then got into a groove with very little support over the second half.
[size=1]"It is hard enough to remember my opinions, without also remembering my reasons for them!" - Friedrich Nietzsche