Final Keeper Victorino/Nolasco or other?

[Philly_05]

I have a open spot on my roster after some winter trades. I'm leaning toward Shane Victorino or Ricky Nolasco. We play fantasy point 12 teams our scoring system is listed bellow. These are my other keepers as of now. I traded for A Rod and Holliday this winter.

Franchise Player- Grady Sizemore
Franchise Player- Hanley Ramirez
Keeper- Johan Santana
Keeper- Matt Holliday
Keeper- Alex Rodriguez
Keeper- Miguel Cabrera
Keeper- Brandon Phillips
Keeper- Alfonso Soriano
Keeper- John Lackey
Keeper- ?
Minors- Matt LaPorta
Minors- Rick Porcello
Minors- Phil Hughes
Minors- Jason Heyward
Minors- Mike Moustakas
Minors- Brett Wallace

Available players to keep for my final major league keeper spot

Shane Victorino, Ricky Nolasco, John Smoltz, Raul Ibanez, Gary Sheffield


Hitters
Single (1)
Double (2)
Triple (3)
Home Run (4)
Run Scored (1)
Run Batted In (1)
Walk or HBP (1)
Sacrifice (1)
Steal (2)
Strikeout (-1)
Error (-1)
Caught Stealing (-1)

Pitchers
Out Recorded (1)
Strikeout (1)
Hit Allowed (-1)
Walk or HBP (-1)
Earned Run (-1)
Quality Start (6)
Hold or Save (6)
Win (4)
Loss (-2)
Blown Save (-2)
Complete Game (5)
Shutout (10)

[clark-e_00@subr.edu]

Ricky Nolasco you haVe stacked Of with
Grady Sizemore
Matt Holliday
Alfonso Soriano
so i would go with the SP

[Diamond Miners]

Ricky Nolasco you haVe stacked Of with
Grady Sizemore
Matt Holliday
Alfonso Soriano
so i would go with the SP

[The_Show]

As stated, your OF is stacked so go with Nolasco. He's really flown under the radar this year since he plays in FLA.

[abrage22]

Ricky Nolasco you haVe stacked Of with
Grady Sizemore
Matt Holliday
Alfonso Soriano
so i would go with the SP

another for this

[San D]

One more vote for Nolasco.

I do wonder though if you could trade Victorino for something better. In some leagues I've played in, there is always someone that overvalues players on the World Series winners due to being over-hyped.

[bigken117]

keep the best player and that's Victorino...though your team is so stacked you could keep Julio Lugo and still win the whole thing.

[Philly_05]

One thing of note that I forgot to tell everyone is that we start 4 OF so if it was Shane Victorino I would have my entire starting OF set going into the year. But only 2 sure things at SP Santana and Lackey with w/e I would get from Hughes.

[oddmanout7]

That team is ridiculous...You have most of the guys that are projected to go in the first round...

I would go with Nolasco, because I think your team needs more pitching than hitting.

[AquaMan2342]

12 team league....ok.

Keep Nolasco.