5x5 Roto, 8 teams, 8 keepers, no limit on the amount of time a player can be kept.
First off, I understand the argument to keep both of these guys over a few of the players listed above. Tulo had a horrible year, but he came on at the end, and I believe his age and ceiling at the thinnest fantasy position make him pretty much a lock. AGone plays first base, which is fairly deep, but he's only under contract thru '10 (though with a team option for '11), and he's put up great numbers everywhere outside of Petco. And Papi...well, he's only going to be DH eligible which is tough, but I think he's still got another elite season or two in him. Those are my thoughts on those guys.
As for the decision, I'll admit to leaning towards Mauer. I've kept him for 2 years now, and I just love watching him hit. That said, if he stays with the Twins for a while, which I have to imagine he will, he'll probably never hit 20 homeruns. Catcher is pretty thin, but there's a few guys I like coming down the pipe. Our league does start two catchers. I like McLouth a lot too. I tabbed him as a guy to target this past season, and it paid off. He could have a bunch of 20/20 seasons ahead of him, but I just get the sense that it probably doesn't actually get any better for him.
Thoughts and comments would be greatly appreciated.