Mookie4ever wrote:Also why should we be looking for mafia more than isk? We kill the isk today and only one townie gets killed during the night. We lynch a mafia and there are still two left to kill at night; the baddies still get two shots at night. We need to kill all three mafia to stop them from killing.
First, as I mentioned earlier, I just think it's harder to find the ISK than the mafia. The ISK can, and probably should, play this game exactly like a regular townie (with a little more self-preservation). The mafia is the biggest threat to the ISK since they get to cast a vote and make a night kill while a townie just gets a vote. Therefore, the ISK is most likely playing this game like a regular townie in trying to dig up evidence for finding the mafia.
Secondly, if the ISK is trying to win, they should be on our side for this round. While I don't like having a second night kill out there, the ISK should at least be using theirs in an attempt to get the mafia. Right now, the ISK might be in a bigger hole than the town after failing to kill a mafia in 4 attempts (2 day votes and 2 night kills).
Finally, we're probably just in a better chance to win if we get one of the mafia tonight instead of the ISK. If we kill the ISK, we'll only be up 4-3 heading into tomorrow. If we kill one of the mafia, we'll be up 5-2-1 heading into tonight. There would be a chance we could lose two townies and only be up 3-2-1 on Day 3, but the mafia and ISK could also do some of our work for us in killing each other.
I still think JT's last post in Day 2 is the most incriminating evidence recently. I never like these two person fights in this game since it draws everyone to one side or the other to the exclusion of everyone else.
Fine Mookie, so I sound like an aww-shucks dumbass. Don't even consider the fact that I chose not to join the bandwagon calling for your death 3 pages back!
But I don't care, it makes sense that Mookie's suspicious of me. I'm suspicious of every single one of you! I can't even decide who to put my vote on. But please notice, Mookie, that I have again decided against randomly slapping my vote on you before shutting down for the night.
wake wrote:Voting off a mafia or especially ISK would've been key for us on day 2. It would've made sense for him to reveal that information, especially with the doctor still around.
Also, It doesn't make much sense that he invesigated a mafia/ISK and kept it secret either. If he did, he would've been voting for them from the very start of day 2. Instead he switched his vote between jfg and Mookie at one point during the day.
I didn't notice anywhere that looked like he was defending Inuk.
Okay, I think the stress of the day had got to me. I read his posts very fast, and when he was talking to Inukchuk, he was talking about someone else. I thought he was talking about him. I definitely agree with you on that point.
If he outs himself and says someone's a mafia, he's dead that night guaranteed (I think). The doc can't save someone that's hit twice, can he? Obviously, that's not a problem if he investigated the ISK because we kill him that day. So, it's safe to assume that if he did find a bad guy, it's a mafioso.
And I do think it makes sense that he would vote for jfg and then unvote if he was trying to be more subtle. By unvoting jfg, he got to explain why jfg was innocent in a manner that seems like it needed to be brought up. idk... maybe I'm overthinking that part, but I think I would be pretty subtle if I were the investigator.
ok, after reading all this, i have come to the conclusion that mookie OR sim, has to to be mafia right? this fight has lasted far too long. sim almost died during day 1 and got off the hook. i still dont know why everyone was so skeptical to knock him off. same with bleach. i am leaning toward sim being more mafia than mookie, but i think voting for sim right now is a lost cause. what else can we do ? we're definitely in the dark here and i dont have much else to go on.