bigken117 wrote:You said in your post it would be easy to see who the mafia was because they would vote for you. So obviously he wasn't going to vote for you. So after much deliberation, I figured you didn't expect a 3rd vote at all while casting yourself in innocence. There was no way the mafia would have exposed themself like that, and everyone but Mookie knew it.
The thing is, with that mindset, the mafia could have voted for me and tried to play it off like that.
I didn't think he would take that chance, because as you can see, it didn't work. And I thought you may have been playing it off like that when you called him out while casting your vote for yourself, knowing the third vote wouldn't come while making yourself look innocent on Day 5 when someone else was lynched and murdered overnight. I guess I could have just waited to see if you made it to Day 5 and voted for ya then...
Oh well, it was fun.
BronXBombers51 wrote:
bigken117 wrote:The investigator gets one search at night, right? So on day 2 he knows only one person's identity?
Yep. Day one I was convinced either teddy or wake was mafia. I asked about teddy that night. Once I found out he was innocent, I planned to ask about wake, but I wound up getting lynched.
So then how could you say with such conviction J was mafia before he stepped up and pretended to be the investigator? I was unconvinced until he did that.
bigken117 wrote:The investigator gets one search at night, right? So on day 2 he knows only one person's identity?
Yep. Day one I was convinced either teddy or wake was mafia. I asked about teddy that night. Once I found out he was innocent, I planned to ask about wake, but I wound up getting lynched.
So then how could you say with such conviction J was mafia before he stepped up and pretended to be the investigator? I was unconvinced until he did that.
I didn't say that J was mafia until he pretended to be the investigator.
I completely stand by my decision to reveal myself. Bronx confirmed I was a townie, so the mafia was going to kill me anyways. I knew chris8 was a townie and I didn't want to go to the grave with that information. J was able to coax you guys into voting off Bronx, otherwise we still would have had the 75% chance I mentioned.
I had another reason as to why dclark couldn't have been mafia by the time I was dead but I can't remember it now.
As to people wondering why I protected chris on Night 1, no one suspected him at all during Day 1, so I figured the mafia would go after the person least suspected, which was him.
Nice job wake. I was on to you on Day 1 but was sidetracked from there.
I haven't played t his game yet, so correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't the mafia have known you were a townie all along, teddy? They wouldn't have known you were the doctor, but if they know each other are mafia, then everyone else they know from square 1 is a townie. No?
bigh0rt wrote:I haven't played t his game yet, so correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't the mafia have known you were a townie all along, teddy? They wouldn't have known you were the doctor, but if they know each other are mafia, then everyone else they know from square 1 is a townie. No?
Correct. But the mafia doesn't want the townies to know for certain that anyone else is a townie. So they usually kill the "most townie" of the townies.
I think the investigator knowing the identity of the doctor is a good twist. It allows him to protect the good doctor throughout the game. It didn't play out since both the investigator and the doctor revealed their identities too soon.
"Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that." ~George Carlin
bigh0rt wrote:I haven't played t his game yet, so correct me if I'm wrong, but wouldn't the mafia have known you were a townie all along, teddy? They wouldn't have known you were the doctor, but if they know each other are mafia, then everyone else they know from square 1 is a townie. No?
Correct. But the mafia doesn't want the townies to know for certain that anyone else is a townie. So they usually kill the "most townie" of the townies.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by 
And I thought you may have been playing it off like that when you called him out while casting your vote for yourself, knowing the third vote wouldn't come while making yourself look innocent on Day 5 when someone else was lynched and murdered overnight. I guess I could have just waited to see if you made it to Day 5 and voted for ya then...
