Braylon Edwards v. Michael Phelps

[StlSluggers]

Braylon Edwards v. Michael Phelps

What's your pick?

[The Artful Dodger]

I'd probably take Phelps though I think Braylon had 16 TD's last season but I'm just saying that because I don't have Braylon on any of my fantasy teams. I reckon he has his share of tough matchups in the coming weeks (Pittsburgh, Giants) that might throw off his TD-a-game pace.

[Yoda]

Isn't it against the rules for Edwards to bet?

[Old_Style]

He might've had 16 TD's last season, but that doesn't mean it's an easily repeatable feat.

Phelps FTW

[BronXBombers51]

Smart money is on Phelps but 16 TDs is certainly within Braylon's capability.

[Amazinz]

Phelps. I realize there were two players last year (Moss & Edwards) but since 1990 there have been less than 10 players with 16 TD+ seasons in the NFL. Randy Moss (3) and Jerry Rice (2) are the only players to do it more than once.

[Yoda]

Phelps. I realize there were two players last year (Moss & Edwards) but since 1990 there have been less than 10 players with 16 TD+ seasons in the NFL. Randy Moss (3) and Jerry Rice (2) are the only players to do it more than once.

Agreed. It's not that easy to score as a WR.

[Simulacrum]

Dang... now I really wish I'd gotten Braylon Edwards in at least one league.

[smoovethug]

Phelps. I realize there were two players last year (Moss & Edwards) but since 1990 there have been less than 10 players with 16 TD+ seasons in the NFL. Randy Moss (3) and Jerry Rice (2) are the only players to do it more than once.

Agreed. It's not that easy to score as a WR.

Aint happenin. My money's on Phelps.

[Davejohnson000]

Edwards doesnt have a chance. He'll be lucky to get 17 receptions let alone TD's the way the Browns have been playing. I bet him this morning at -500 to not win the bet at this site:
http://www.inspin.com/nfl/braylon-edwar ... -1708.html
Seems like a cheap price . Last season he had 2 TD's after the first 2 games and went on to get 16 for the season. This year after 1st 2 games ...zilch!