Mookie4ever wrote:I just read all of this.
First of all why would the doctor reveal himself? And why did the investigator reveal himself? The investigator should only reveal himself if he has found a mafia. In the case of finding a mafia the investigator is sacrificed to kill off a mafia (the remaining mafia kills him that night or the next if the doctor kills him). Investigator for mafia is a fair trade because the townies outnumber the mafia by so much.
The doctor and the investigator revealing themselves to point out a simple townie does not make sense. The doctor and the investigator are very valuable and to sacrifice themselves (b/c they have now made themselves targets) to protect a regular townie who is not as valuable as them makes no sense. I have come to the conclusion that they are either mafia protecting each other or just made a bad play.
Bronx's assertion that the moderator revealed to him the identity of the doctor is ridiculous. He is lying which makes it sure that he and Teddy are the two remaining mafia trying to protect each other. If he is telling the truth then Yoda has screwed up the game. If Yoda did this he has to step in and confirm that Bronx is telling the truth and thereby confirming the identity of te doctor and the investigator and ruining the game. If Yoda does not speak up then Bronx is lying and he is mafia and Teddy is probably mafia as well.
I'm going to wait to hear from Yoda. If he confirms what Bronx has said then I will vote for J. If Yoda says nothing in the next few hours then I will say that the two remaining mafia are Bronx and Teddy.
I only revealed myself as investigator because it appeared as if I was going to be lynched today. That would do even less good for the townies. At least now, I can stick around for another day and give more information tomorrow. If I was lynched today, that wouldn't be possible.
And essentially, the townie's have gotten their mafia in this scenario anyway, with J's emergence.
Yoda did reveal to me that teddy was the doctor. I don't know if that was against the rules or not, but is the truth.