Mookie will not last in this game more than a few days. He is a solid player. If he is a townie, the mafia knows Mook will sniff them out, so he will be the first one offed by them. And if our friendly doctor protects him tonight, they will get him tomorrow. So if he is alive on Day 3, there is a strong chance he is part of the mafia. Get him then. But maybe the mafia wants to try and get a bandwagon rolling for him and try to eliminate two townies (we lynch Mook and one they get) in one night.
So I am thinking that some mafioso may have already cast ballots on him. Don't suspect chris much yet. Don't have reservations yet on BB51 though read about others having doubts, but I will go back to my original vote, even though my more recent one has made no effort to defend himself.
teddy ballgame wrote:I'm sticking with wake. I just don't see it being Mookie or Bronx at this point. A few people have said they agreed with my reasoning on wake, so I'm asking you guys to vote on it if you agree. I get the feeling a lot of people vote for Mookie because he's Mookie, and not necessarily because of his actions in the game. Maybe that's wrong but it seems like every day of every game there's a few votes for him.
See, either Teddy is playing this game good or he is townie. I don't think a mafioso would want to stick his neck out there and try to lead everyone into a vote of Wake....mafioso just wouldn't do that....I don't think.
So that leaves me with Wake left from my list....I'd like to hear more from him if we could...
teddy ballgame wrote:I'm sticking with wake. I just don't see it being Mookie or Bronx at this point. A few people have said they agreed with my reasoning on wake, so I'm asking you guys to vote on it if you agree. I get the feeling a lot of people vote for Mookie because he's Mookie, and not necessarily because of his actions in the game. Maybe that's wrong but it seems like every day of every game there's a few votes for him.
See, either Teddy is playing this game good or he is townie. I don't think a mafioso would want to stick his neck out there and try to lead everyone into a vote of Wake....mafioso just wouldn't do that....I don't think.
So that leaves me with Wake left from my list....I'd like to hear more from him if we could...
Teddy also came to a pretty solid defense of Mookie. I'm not saying his point was a bad one, but there is a possibility teddy and Mook are both mafia and Wake is innocent.
On the other hand, I also think that the points about Mookie being dead soon if he is a townie are valid. So maybe letting him hang around and see what becomes of him is the smarter play, and we should go after someone else. I'm not sure who else I'd vote for, though. I think one of teddy or wake is mafia, but I'm not sure which.
teddy ballgame wrote:I'm sticking with wake. I just don't see it being Mookie or Bronx at this point. A few people have said they agreed with my reasoning on wake, so I'm asking you guys to vote on it if you agree. I get the feeling a lot of people vote for Mookie because he's Mookie, and not necessarily because of his actions in the game. Maybe that's wrong but it seems like every day of every game there's a few votes for him.
See, either Teddy is playing this game good or he is townie. I don't think a mafioso would want to stick his neck out there and try to lead everyone into a vote of Wake....mafioso just wouldn't do that....I don't think.
So that leaves me with Wake left from my list....I'd like to hear more from him if we could...
It's a combination of being fairly confident with my vote and wanting to move the game along.
I've really got nothing else to go on....I'll just admit that right now. I'm going to jump on the Inukchuk bandwagon because it looks like we might hit Day 2 if we do...
J35J wrote:I've really got nothing else to go on....I'll just admit that right now. I'm going to jump on the Inukchuk bandwagon because it looks like we might hit Day 2 if we do...
Vote: Inukchuk
I find the 5th vote to be more suspicious than the 6th vote. Mafia might be reluctant to kill a townie because it brings instant attention to them. But slyly voting 5th to try to tip the scales....
And you were second on Stephen Colbert's list...which meant at the time I made that...you were second on my list.
Inukchuk has been a little mysterious, but I'd say not so much more so than others.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by 
