Scherzer/Hughes/Gio

[jmudukes2008]

I'd go with Gio, but keep on eye on Hughes because he'll most likely be in the rotation as of next sunday.

[hybrid]

I'd go with Gio, but keep on eye on Hughes because he'll most likely be in the rotation as of next sunday.

Yanks said he is making another AAA start before coming back up.

[Yoda]

The issue with Petit is that he is still giving up too many HR. I think that Scherzer will bounce him off the rotation soon.

[kab21]

Quality of impact rank
Scherzer
Hughes - They also found an eyesight problem IIRC when he got injured, he might pull a Rick 'Wild Thing' Vaughn on his return
Gio - I'm really not sold on him being a good pitcher this season - still talented though

Quantity of impact rank
Gio
Hughes
Scherzer - he'll be called up the last out of this 3 IMO, but he's pretty good

[hybrid]

The issue with Petit is that he is still giving up too many HR. I think that Scherzer will bounce him off the rotation soon.

And Davis just gives up to much of everything else.

[jmudukes2008]

I'd go with Gio, but keep on eye on Hughes because he'll most likely be in the rotation as of next sunday.

Yanks said he is making another AAA start before coming back up.

Yeah I know...not this sunday, next sunday