Yoda wrote:The point is, neither of them is head and shoulder above the other. Utley = in his peak. MCab = in his pre-peak. Therefore MCab > Utley.
Yoda, I agree that neither is head and shoulder better than the other and for next year I probably will rank Miggy higher for once. I posted this thread for this exact reason, neither is head and shoulders better than the other and this creates a great debate. If I was just here to gloat I would have posted this earlier in the season when Utley clearly had the best stats. Right now their stats are very close and it appears MCAB will finish with better numbers since MCAB is hotter now. However if Utley gets hot and MCAB cools then, Utley has the better numbers. Those that call this a poorly timed thread just don't get what I was trying to do which was to create debate. I mean whats the point in debating two players that are obviously miles apart in talent, should we debate Andy Gonzalez and AROD?
This is what I like about Yoda he posts things that make sense, most of the time, other times well thats when there is a debate.
Give Snakes his due!!!! Snakes deserves the fantasy expert icon!!! Go Snakes!!!!