Yoda wrote:That Utley has been better this year doesn't change the fact that Miggy > Utley. Miggy was better in 07 and this year was an adjustment period to the AL. I'd like to see Utley put up his numbers in a more neutral park.
The only reason Miggy was better in '07 was because Utley got hit and broke his hand/wrist. Normalize their at-bats (not even considering that Utley came back and wasn't the same, so he had three weeks or so of at-bats at a lesser rate) and Utley has a better line than Miggy for '07.
I'm still an Utley>Miggy believer, though they are very close, but I agree with the others that I don't see any reason for an "I told you so" thread to be posted on the cafe.