Hart Vs. Markakis.

[The_Natural]

The old thread was Hart Vs Pence Vs. Markakis.

I think we can take Pence out now.

Who is your vote now?

I'm going with Hart. Remember he has Yost as a manager.

[jake_twothousandfive]

It's pretty close but Markakis is usually huge in the second half so I'm going to go with him.

[Bosy Billups]

Adam Jones

[J.C.Fighter]

Hart. Love the high avg and power /speed combo

[deerayfan072]

I love having both in my OF with Bay and McLouth also available

[Yoda]

I'd say Hart. He runs a bit more and their power should be similar.

[Maris09]

Hart because he runs more, and because the lineup around him gives him the edge in Runs and RBI.

[soty]

Like them both, but I have to give the slight edge to Hart because of the SBs.

[AquaMan2342]

In most fantasy formats, I'd take Hart because of his production in the counting categories.

In real life, I'd take Markakis and it isn't even close.

[APAP]

I owned both in my Dynasty up until very recently where I moved Markakis as part of a deal. At the time of the trade Markakis had around 30-35 more points than Hart. I looked at the walk column and saw that Markakis had about 30 more walks, which made up for the 30 points disparity (with my league giving a point per walk). I think that if Hart just gets more discipline at the plate to take more pitches, he's just as good as Markakis if not better. I definitely think he has more power and speed. Both are very solid though.