Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **Vladdy the Impaler** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 9:42 pm

Mine is as follows:

Definite Top 5
1 Piazza
2 Pudge
3 Posada
4 Javy
5 Kendall

Toss-up
6 Lieberthal
7 Varitek
8 Lo Duca
9 Martinez
10 Mauer

i have high hopes for mauer and victor(y) this year... what are your thoughts on those guys and how do ur lists go...

by **kentx12** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 9:48 pm

Posada
Piazza
Pudge
Javy
Varitek
Lieberthal
Kendal
Phillips
Lecroy
Loduca

by **Pogotheostrich** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 10:43 pm

Posada
Piazza
Javy
I-Rod
Kendall
Varitek
Lieberthal
Pierzinski
Hernandez
LeCroy

by **KDOGG** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 10:47 pm

posada
pudge
javy
piazza
varitek
kendall
lieberthal
pierzinski
jason phillips
martinez
mauer
hernandez

by **Spartans Rule** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:25 pm

1. Piazza
2. Posada
3. Pudge
4. Javy
5. Varitek
6. Kendall
7. Phillips
8. LoDuca
9. Lieberthal
10. LeCroy

Most overrated: Kendall - he doesn't hit for power, he doesn't run anymore, its unlikely he hits .325 again and the Pirates lineup has been dismantled.

Most underrated: Phillips - a talented young player who will be under a lot of radars and some may not realize he qualifies at catcher. Could do something like .300/15/70.

by **Talyn** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:31 pm

1. Posada
2. Piazza
3. Lopez
4. Rodriguez
5. Varitek
6. Lieberthal
7. Phillips
8. Pierzynski
9. Kendall
10. Martinez

by **Cornbread Maxwell** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:32 pm

Spartans Rule wrote:1. Piazza
2. Posada
3. Pudge
4. Javy
5. Varitek
6. Kendall
7. Phillips
8. LoDuca
9. Lieberthal
10. LeCroy

Most overrated: Kendall - he doesn't hit for power, he doesn't run anymore, its unlikely he hits .325 again and the Pirates lineup has been dismantled.

No - the most overrated is easily your #8. Has he done anything since 2001?

Piazza
Posada
Lopez
Irod
Kendall
Varitek
Lieberthal
Pierzinski
Phillips
LeCroy

by **Spartans Rule** » Tue Mar 02, 2004 11:46 pm

Cornbread Maxwell wrote:
No - the most overrated is easily your #8. Has he done anything since 2001?

Well, its hard for me to go to bat for LoDuca since I don't really like him either. But I will say this about him: He hits for a respectable average and posts decent R and RBI totals for a catcher just by virtue of playing every day.

He's been grossly overrated the past two years on the strength of 2001, thats for sure. But I think this year there may be an overreaction in the opposite direction, as he's burned so many people they'll just completely ignore him. 2001 was a total fluke, and he'll never match that. But he isn't totally useless, and could come at a good value this year.

by **eli81k** » Wed Mar 03, 2004 1:47 am

I wouldn't mind taking LoDuca this season. Did you read that player news blurb on Yahoo? He added like 30 pounds of muscle in the offseason? I dont' mind cashing in on his roid-use.

50 homeruns and zits on his testicles are soon to follow.

by **mbuser** » Wed Mar 03, 2004 3:08 am

eli81k wrote:50 homeruns and zits on his testicles are soon to follow.

i almost fell out of my seat when i read that :-D

and my top 10

posada
piazza
lopez
irod
kendall
lecroy
phillips
varitek
pierzynski
lieberthal

Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

who are YOUR top 10 C

who are YOUR top 10 C

Who is online