Vetoable

[Jimmy103]

12 teams
runs, hits, hr, rbi, sb, ba, ops
w, l, sv, k, era, whip, k/9

Team 1 (2nd place, 97-64-7)
c- Kenji Johjima
1b- Prince Fielder
2b- Dustin Pedroia
3b- Ryan Braun
ss- Jimmy Rollins
of- Michael Bourn
of- JD Drew
of- Jeff Francouer
util- Mark Teixeira
util- Randy Winn
bn- Matt Kemp
bn- Adrian Beltre
dl- Gary Sheffield

sp- Josh Beckett
sp- Erik Bedard
sp- Jeremy Guthrie
sp- John Lackey
rp- Chad Quaills
rp- Jose Valverde
rp- Jon Raunch
p- Dana Eveland
p- Brandon Morrow
p- Santiago Castilla
bn- Alex Hinshaw
bn- Scott Downs


Team 2 (12th place, 48-114-6)
c- Joe Mauer
1b- Todd Helton
2b- BJ Upton
3b- Jorge Cantu
ss- Troy Tulowitzi
of- Grady Sizemore
of- Carlos Beltran
of- Jacoby Ellsbury
util- Richie Weeks
util- Fred Lewis
bn- Jeff Baker
bn- Orlando Hudson
bn- Jarrod Saltalamacchia
dl- Rafael Furcal

sp- Justin Verlander
sp- Jon Lester
sp- Chris Young
sp- Daniel Cabrera
rp- Jonathan Papelbon
rp- Jonathan Broxton
rp- Jorge Campillo
p- Pedro Martinez
p- Clayton Kershaw
p- Bartolo Colon
bn- Clay Buchholz
bn- Rafael Soriano


Team 1 Trades: Mark Teixeira, JD Drew, Adrian Beltre, Santiago Castillo
Team 2 Trades: Grady Sizemore, BJ Upton, Jonathan Papelbon

[WaCougMBS]

I dont think its vetoable, because Team A is giving up solid run production and power potential to get SBs and Runs more than anything. Papelbon's appearance in the deal makes it an advantage for the Sizemore/Upton side for sure, but by no means do I think that this deal is vetoable...

Hope this helps

[AEMRICH]

agreed i don't think that this trade should be vetoed. They are both giving up solid players while team 2 is giving up the better overall package in sizemore/upton/paps i don't think it is super lopsided
viewtopic.php?t=356179

[AquaMan2342]

Beltre and Tex are two notable second half studs. Two is getting the better end but not necessarily by much. What if Street gets traded? Casilla's value likely goes through the roof or at least bumps the shingles.