Are there any guys that you still haven't dropped and have just been cancerous to your team's success?
On one of my teams, I have pretty much only started AJ Burnett when he gets destroyed.
My overall team line is 562.2 IP 41 W 43 S 541 K 3.35 ERA 1.29 WHIP, which has still been dominant and I lead that league by a wide margin so it's really why he's still around.
From my team log, here is Burnett's contribution:
52.1 IP 2 W 53 K 7.22 ERA 1.72 WHIP
Without him, my ratios plummet to a 2.95 ERA and 1.13 WHIP. Without Burnett or replacing his innings, I lose no points in Wins and ERA, drop 2 in Ks, and gain SEVEN in WHIP.
It was sad when I calculated this today after his latest thrashing and realized one player has cost me 5 points.