Who to keep V Martinez or D Young

[SonsofSlam04]

I am torn as to who to keep, I know V Martinez is highly touted but he has yet to prove himself. D Young this year will qualify in my league at 3B and the OF .. Which guy should I keep? ... 10 team H2H league. Current keepers are ARod, Prior, Schilling, Berkman, B Giles, Blalock, Contreras.. VMartinez or D Young? Thanks to all who reply!

[Fumbler]

I think the biggest factor will be which position do you think will have more depth after the other owners keep their players -- catcher or third base?

It's tough to say for me without knowing who might be available. Personally, i don't think either Martinez or Young would be considered true keepers.

[HOOTIE]

Young. 25 hrs 90 rbis not bad at 3b.

[hooligan1]

Depends. Young is very, very good. Martinez seems like he will be good, but....... My guess is that if you don't keep Martinez, somebody else will nab him.