I would do this trade. Your ideal OF should be 1) McLouth 2) CG 3)Ellsbury 4) Nady 5)Ibanez. I'm not a real big fan of any KC players right now, that entire team is offensively inept. If you can get him to bite on Ibanez instead of Dye, I would do that as well. Can you live with probably 5-10 fewer homers and 10-20 fewer rbi's (what I would expect is the trade-off between replacement production in Ibanez and Dye) for 8-10 W's, 3.5-4.0era pitcher, decent WHIP, and 90+ K's from this point of the season on?