Tulo or O Cab Long Term?

[felixthecat011]

By "long term" I mean the rest of the seaon. I'm in a non-keeper, 10 team, 5x5 rotisserie league.

I traded for O Cab just before he got hot but had Tulo on IR to eventually replace him. Now I'm not so sure, since I will be dropping O Cab to activate Tulo...

O Cab provides more balanced production than Tulo, although TT has the advantage in power/RBIs...

Thoughts?

[WTP]

Cabrera's coming off a great season, but his numbers last year were pretty flukish. He put up the highest BABIP of his career last year, and he was 32. At 33 this year, he's not a good bet at all to repeat those numbers, and it's showing so far.

Tulo is going to be coming off some significant injury time, and should be a little rusty when he returns. Still, after a week or so of getting back in the groove, it's hard to believe he won't outproduce OCab in every category but SBs. If you can leave Tulo on the DL until he shows signs of life, that'd be the best option.

[fbc_fan]

i'd take tulo over ocab even with the injury. as the poster above said, ocab's numbers were babip induced last year.

this question should probably go here though:

viewforum.php?f=26

you'll get more responses and analysis than in the leftovers.