I would love to see him stay at 4th. Love the thought of Maggs ahead of him. I think Miggs is a better bad ball hitter than Maggs and so wouldn't be hurt as much by not having a big bat behind him.
Totally agree with you there. I really like Mags in the 3 spot and Cabrera batting clean-up. Maggs really isn't a number four hitter as he is lacking some power. He will still get his RBI opportunities and the fact that he hits a lot of singles to drive runs in just means he'll be on base more for Cabrera. Not to mention, assuming they bat Guillen in the 5th spot, that should provide decent protection for Cabrera.