Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **prodpaul** » Mon Mar 03, 2003 8:51 am

Buehrle was picked right before me in the 4th round and I took Maddux. Was Maddux the better pick? I seem to think so. I didn't even have Buehrle on my list.

by **superotto80** » Mon Mar 03, 2003 9:41 am

i would take maddox only because he has been so consistent for so long plus he plays on a better team, as far buerhle he isnt far behind he did win 19 games last year and the white sox could be pretty good.

by **trevisc** » Mon Mar 03, 2003 10:12 am

I would have taken maddux too. Just last year Maddux was a first/early 2nd round pitcher. Now all of a sudden he's a bargain basement pitcher because he was a little hurt last year. Don't believe the hype. Maddux is good for a sub 3.00 era and 18 wins this year.

by **Oswalt11** » Mon Mar 03, 2003 11:12 am

Buerhle and Maddux are both good picks. The only reason i would pick Buerhle is becuz of Maddux's health risk. Although he isnt an injury prone player, he's about 8 years older than Buerhle. Both are gonna win close to 20 games, if healthy.

by **THE MASHER** » Mon Mar 03, 2003 2:58 pm

Maddux was the better pick. Buehrle in the 4th round is a reach (I'd say 7th- 8th round) Maddux is superior in ERA and WHIP. The other 2 categories are probably a wash, but I'd definitely take my shot w/ the Mad Dog!

Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

Maddux or Buehrle

Maddux or Buehrle

close

Who is online