Max Scherzer/Morrow for Bucholz_whir

[Members Only Jackets]

Hi

Since it's minor leaguers, I decided to post in here.

I give:
Clay Bucholz

I get:
Max Scherzer
Brandon Morrow(starter down the road I hope?)

I'm a few years away....do I make the move or stay put?

thanks

[cardinal1975]

I think both Scherzer and Morrow(definitely in the pen)could be closers in a few years. The Dbacks should give Scherzer every chance to stay in the rotation, but I beleive I would rather have Buchholz in two years. He just seems safer. THe only downside with Buchholz has been his inability to stay healthy for a full season. It's close but I go with Buchholz.

[jwhands]

I like Scherzer and Morrow. They both have an electric fastball and will be completely dominating if they can further develop their secondary pitches. Morrow held his own last year with just a fastball, so that should give you an idea of his potential.

[bigken117]

I would hang on to Buchholz. He's got no chance of a long term move to the pen like the other two do.