KOCH, GRAVES, or CHACON - Battle of the Scrub Closers

[Vladdy the Impaler]

predictions / any worth a look?

[RynMan]

i wouldnt count on any of those 3 guys as my no. 1 closer. but i have shacon on my roster for the fact that on yahoo he is listed as a starting pitcher - therfore i can use him in those SP spots when the two starters are on their days off. i see him as being a decent lower tier closer.....better than graves and koch.

[Vladdy the Impaler]

graves qualifies at SP too... gotta like that versatility as well.

[MikeeDee]

I rank them:
Graves
Koch
Chacon

All third closers if at all if you ask me.

[KolbSaves]

graves qualifying as sp only matters if you're going to play 6 relievers at a time (yahoo default settings)

[RynMan]

what scares me about these 3 guys are the bad rotations hey have in front of them - therefore their save opportunities. if kolb was on another team i think he would be alot higher valued. if you look at it that way, i guess u have to say koch but he was really bad last year with the same staff.....

[L0rdB23]

i know graves is probably the saftest bet but i actually think chacon has the most upside..

he was very good as a starter in colorado and i think he has the stuff to suceed as a closer their

id rank them :

chacon.. whose gonna take his job??.. turk wendell??? ..LOL
graves/koch .. neither of these guys are safe with ryan wagner and marte around

[baseball genius]

I rank em

Chacon
Graves
Koch

[WharfRat]

Graves is the man, steady as hell and experienced. Koch can go batty (witness last year's implosion). Chacon is interesting, that's why I pulled him out of the free agent bin. He's an x-factor.

[gypsyspot]

I go

Chacon
Graves
Koch

Only because chacon seems to have the closer job pinned down a little better than the others.