which combo of players would u rather have?

[RynMan]

Manny Ramirez + Johan Santana
or
Mark Teixeira + Josh Beckett
or
Mark Teixeira + (a starter equal in value to Manny)

??? which would you rather have? if number 3, who would the pitcher be?

[swarmee]

Mark Teixeira + (a starter equal in value to Manny)

I would say that Schilling and Manny are pretty even, and I'd prefer to have Tex and Schilling by a hair over Manny and Santana.

[Pogotheostrich]

Manny Ramirez + Johan Santana

[mightyian5]

since the tex duo isnt for sure, id take manny and santana

[Transmogrifier]

What an odd way to ask a question--seems like "help me draft", but masking it in another way...


Anyway, Take Manny and Johan.

[RynMan]

oh no....you found me out.

[Andy1234]

I'd take #3, Mark Teixeira + (a starter equal in value to Manny)

And I would say that starter is someone like Schilling, Halladay, or Wood

[RynMan]

do u think teix will hit as many HR's as manny? for some reason i dont see it as a far out prediction.........manny will have a better average and RBI's though

[Jer19G]

#1 for me please.

[NittanyLions]

id take #3, though i wouldnt mind having #1...teixeira will be good, but i dont see any manny-like power hitting, but hes still got a good chance of bcoming a star