Which D-Back THIS year Upton or Reynolds?

[shamus]

Long term upside is obviously with Upton, but a better question is which of these two players is more likely to break out this year and have more value?

[AllDay]

I'd gamble on Upton for this year. He needs to move up in the order to obtain good value, which I think will make him a better 2nd half player. I read an article that said it was likely to happen at some point - but I suppose if he really struggles he could continue to bat in the bottom of the order. Snyder was moved out of the 5 hole so I suppose nothing is set in stone there.

Reynolds started off hot last year too, then fizzled before recovering again. He's a bit streaky so until he can deliver consistently I'd go with the vastly higher upside in Upton.