Guardado or Hoffman..........

[shuffcard]

I have both in a cbs H2H points league & would like to trade one of them either for another starting pitcher or a hitter.

Who do you expect to have the best year. I really like both of them. I'm comfortable w/ hoffman b/c he was able to come back at the end of last year and guardado will get a lot of chances in seatle.

What do you think??????

[Fumbler]

Personally i like Hoffman...but if you're not a gambling man, the safe choice would be Guardado.

[chinch sacs]

Go with Eddie

[BobbyRoberto]

I say Guardado. There's another thread here about Hoffman having a 40% tear in his rotator cuff. That's enough for me to bump him down a bit. Guardado is solid and Safeco Field is a great pitcher's park.

[kentx12]

Every day Eddie

[jbuk]

Go with Eddie, Hoffmans injury sounds way too risky.

[bell]

I'll take another angle and say Guardado would give you more trade value.

[DieHardCubbie]

I agree you will get move back for Eddie....but I would be more comfortable moving Hoffman and Keeping Eddie...

[Madison]

I'd keep Guardado and trade Hoffman.