KCollins1304 wrote:You would think with Questar(I think they still have that, the umpire tracker) they could measure how many pitches were called strikes outside of the strike zone.
Steve-o wrote:MLB does that. It's my understanding that umpires get reports on how the called the game after they call the game in those parks. Somebody let me know if this isn't the case...
KCollins1304 wrote:Yeah I know they evaluate the umpires, I meant like a database that was available for fantasy purposes.
Steve-o wrote:The Questec and umpire reports are kept private. It would be sweet to see how "bad" or "good" umpires are at calling balls and strikes though.
I came to the same conclusion last year after I saw the Cubs - Reds game
when Lohse and Lilly combined for 22 Ks.
So I started to evaluate HP umpires, how they are calling the strike zone.
But since Im not wathing many games, its a small sample size, and most of the umpires did well.
Two of the top three K/9 leaders last year, Tom Hallion and Andy Fletcher called strikes were in the zone when I saw them. They didnt give more to the pitcher.
Not like Doug Eddings in that Cubs - Reds game. Hitters should have used bats twice as long to be able to reach those pitches he called strikes.
The other guy I saw givin a bigger zone was Ed Montague. But he wasnt that much out of the zone and was consistent, so hitters could adjust.
And one other guy needs to be mentioned, Larry Poncino. He might just had a bad day, but he had no idea where the strike zone was. Nobody, no hitters no pitchers knew what the pitch is gonna be called. Cant remember what game that was.