I'll give you a start. Please don't think I'm picking on you, just trying to help.
A-Rod up. Beltran, Prior Down. Soriano Up. Helton Up. Pedro Down.
My top rankings go:
The next few IMO should be Nomar, Manny, Maggs, Sheffield, Bonds, Pedro, Kent
Posada, Kendall, Variteck, Lopez, Piazza, Gagne, Wagner are way too high IMO (if you notice a pattern, I'm saying your C and CL's are too high)
Maggs is way too low
Ensberg and A. Ramirez are also too high
hopefullly this gives you a start and helps