Thought I'd dig a few of them up for some laughs...these gems are only from 1 thread...
jeter is the captain. he has done more for that team that probably arod ever will. after all he has done you cannot strip him of his position and give it to a newcomer. i dread the day when arod says he doesn't feel comfortable at short and steinbrenner wants joe to make a switch.
if it came right down to it i wouldnt trade jeter straight up for anybody in the game because of what he does when it really matters, as said before, stuff that doesn't show up on a statsheet.
if you have watched jeter throughout his career you'd know his ability and acheivements cannot be summarized in one series, nor on a statsheet. maybe its too hard for you to understand but jeter deserves the spot much more than arod regardless of whether arod is a better fielder....
Jeter has had more clutch moments than anyone. I can't even remember alot of them because he's done it his whole career. There's been many times where he steps up and gets that key hit. Nomar may have that ability but he hasn't shown it on the level Jeter has. Nobody in baseball has shown it on the level Jeter has for the amount of times Jeter has.
Maybe because your not Yankee fans you don't belive in clutch. Maybe us Yankee fans are the only ones who believe because WE are the team that always arises in the most unlikely times. There has been a surplus of moments over the past decade in which the Yankees seemed down and out but somehow they come back fighting. Maybe THAT is why we believe. Maybe your teams do, maybe not. But I know nobody has done it like the Yankees have. I don't care what you call it, clutch, ora, whatever. The Yankees always find a way to come back when you least expect it. That is why we believe and you don't. So don't jump all over us because there is no factual proof. There is no denying the Yankees have shocked us all, especially over the last decade. If you deny that then you just don't know what your talking about.
I debated with myself whether or not I should resurrect some of this stuff. It really hurts to read it. Yet after just a little exposure to the Cafe...
So, in order to be a Yankee fan, I must kiss Derek Jeter's a**? Jeter is one of my favorite players. As I said before, A-Rod will never touch Jeter in my book (in terms of my favorite players, A-Rod is obviously the better player). That doesn't give me the right to spew lies about Jeter, making him better than he is, and making A-Rod worse than he is.
Jeter is a winner? How? How is a player a winner? Because they win a World Series? In that case, Luis Sojo is a winner. So is Mariano Duncan. Ooh, let's not forget Clay Bellinger. Let me ask you a question...if the Kansas City Royals had drafted Jeter, would he still be a winner? If the Yankees had drafted A-Rod, would he be a winner? Ted Williams, Barry Bonds and Don Mattingly never won World Series. Aren't they in the same boat as A-Rod then? All of them...LOSERS!!
Yankee fans don't boo Jeter because they are obsessed with Jeter. They truly believe that Jeter is the greatest thing since sliced bread, and that he can do no wrong. He's captain clutch and he has calm eyes.
Jeter isn't clutch. Jeter is simply a very good player. He goes through hot streaks and slumps, just as every player does. Jeter has had good postseason series, and he's had HORRIBLE postseason series. When you think of Jeter's postseason or as many like to call "clutch" play, what might you think of? The flip-play? Yes. The walkoff homerun in the World Series? Yes.
Little does anyone know that Jeter batted .148 in the 2001 World Series. Sure, he hit that homerun, but perhaps had he done anything in that series, the Yankees wouldn't have lost. He was the worst player on the field for the Yankees for a good 2 week stretch of that October. And the Yankees lost, so it's not like his poor performance was overshadowed by a Yankee championship.
But does anyone blast Jeter? No. Do they blame him for the 2001 loss? No. What do they do? They name him frigging Mr. November.
I don't claim to know what I'm talking about today, either , but I'm quite amazed at how the Cafe has changed my perspective on the game. This is just one example...again from only one thread. I can dig up a lot more stuff, but I don't want to further subject you (or me) to it.
So basically what I'm trying to say is....thanks. The FBC has really been more than just a fantasy baseball website for me. For a kid who is now in college trying to make it as a sports writer, the amount of knowledge that this place has offered me has really been invaluable. There is no doubt in my mind that this place has made me a better fan, and has even put me in a better position to get a career in the sports world. I've really learned about baseball through this place. And I'm still learning, which is what is so great about this place.
I really just wanted to take the time to say thank you. So thanks to menyak, Arlo and Mad for creating/running this place. Thanks to all the mods, except Mookie ( ). And thanks to everyone else who posts here and shares their baseball knowledge on a daily basis. There's way too many of you to name.
PS: I look forward to celebrating the Yankees 27th championship with you all later this year!