Wieters or Carlos Gonzalez

[JDROX]

AL Only
5x5 Auction

Wieters or Carlow Gonzalez?

I have the first pick and am deciding between the two. Wieters is at a better position and Gonzalez (if he starts the year in the Minors will be available) could make an impact this year.

Considering the entire situation of Gonzalez helping immediatley what are your thoughts?

[thomasps3]

AL only, if there is any question, take Wieters. His position is really scarce, and in your last post I spoke to why I would take Wieters over Price as well....

[JDROX]

thanks

[kimchi_chigae]

Wieters is the better pick long term, not because he's a catcher, but because he's the better prospect. If you need someone who can help you this year, then you have to go with Gonzalez.

[Grounded Polo]

Definitely Wieters based off better position and more talent.

[jwhands]

Go with the talent and work ethic, take Wieters.

[Hrbek85]

I would go with Gonzalez.

You might get Wieters at #4. You might even get Price at #4.

Or ask the guy with picks #2 and #3 if he wants to trade.

[Koby Schellenger]

Wieters for sure. No question. He's a better player and at a more scarce position.