I am suprised that some of you guys are picking players already in their peak years. I love Sanatana and Pujols as much as anyone, but 5 years from now when they are 34ish? ARod will be pushing 40. Not so sure about that. Its also real tough to go with pitching a well since they are statistically more injury prone than hitters. You can make a real strong case for Verlander, Hamels, Kazmir, or King Felix as these guys are all just about to enter their prime.
I guess Im not so brave to pick a P though. Tough to make a decision between Wright and Cabrera - as was pointed out, Wright is more versatile, but I think we are seeing the next Pujols in Cabrera. And since Im an admitted homer, I will go with the guy the Tigers locked up for the next 8 years.