NEED SOME CRITIQUING ....PLEASE

[huejazz808]

This is a breakdown of the roster slots in the league Im in. Do you think It can work ? Any input would be great. Its a 10 team H2H-points.Weekly lineup changes.
(c-1b-2b-3b-ss-0f-0f-0f-util-sp-sp-sp-rp) 7 bench
1=1.5
2=2.5
3=3.5
HR=5
R=1
RBI=1
SB=2
BB=1
IBB=1
K= -1
GIDP= -1
DPT=1
(bonus)GS=3 CYC=7
W=12
L= -3
SV=5
K=1
QS=1
RW=3
ER= -.5
BB= -.25
HR= -1
(Bonus) SHO=3 CG=3 NH=5 PG=7
Does 1point per innings pitch work?

[stevethumb]

yikes !!!! too much math in that league 4 me !!! anyway, welcome to the cafe

[talan37]

Off the top of my head it looks like your overvaluing slap hitters who rarely strike out.

If your going to count GIDP, it should probably be more negative than a K, since I would much rather have a guy that k's 20 times, than a guy who GIDP 20 times.

I am not that familiar with points leagues, but I believe 1B/2B/3B/HR should be normalized to total bases.(so 1,2,3,4 or 2,4,6,8)

I am not a big fan of the GS/CYC as they are are too random to predict to any degree. Just my .02$ GL.