Brignac or Antonelli

[speedy27]

who would you rather have in you minor league farm system? I've currently got Brignac along with Moustakas, Cardenas, Hu along with Tim Beckham (HS).

Would you consider trading Brignac for Antonelli or stick with the crew i've currently got?

[High Heater]

i personaly preffer Antonelli... i just think he'll end up a good 20-25/20-25 type threat at middle with a good average and good enough defense to stick there. brignac has soured some in my eyes and many others with his performace last year. he'll be a good hitter just i dont think he'll be the star some thought he would become.

[jwhands]

I like Brignac over Antonelli, especially with your current farm structure. You have Moustakas (who will be moving to 3b), Brignac at ss, and Cardenas at 2b. Why would you want to add another 2b prospect to your roster? Plus, Antonelli will abe hitting in a pitchers park, so don't expect huge power numbers from him in the beginning.

[Grounded Polo]

i personaly preffer Antonelli... i just think he'll end up a good 20-25/20-25 type threat at middle with a good average and good enough defense to stick there. brignac has soured some in my eyes and many others with his performace last year. he'll be a good hitter just i dont think he'll be the star some thought he would become.

That's alot of power you're projecting for Antonelli, especially considering his ballpark.

[kimchi_chigae]

I would keep Brignac, unless the other owner offers something more. I really like Antonelli, but you have to take Brignac over him, especially with the Petco factor.

[speedy27]

thanks i'll keep brignac....i offered him up for antonelli and luckily for me the owner rejected and ask for j.bruce instead.

[Steve-o]

thanks i'll keep brignac....i offered him up for antonelli and luckily for me the owner rejected and ask for j.bruce instead.

That's ridiculous. I hate dealing with owners like that. Antonelli for Bruce. yeah. That's fair. Seriously. Give me that guys email address and I'll send him a note for you.