Rank these two teams. WHIR

[jlm53089]

Trashmen
1. (4) Johan Santana SP
2. (17) Carlos Beltrán OF
3. (24) Mark Teixeira 1B
4. (37) Derek Jeter SS
5. (44) John Lackey SP
6. (57) Joe Nathan RP
7. (64) Torii Hunter OF
8. (77) Scott Kazmir SP
9. (84) Hideki Matsui OF
10. (97) Mariano Rivera RP
11. (104) Fausto Carmona SP
12. (117) Kelly Johnson 2B
13. (124) James Shields SP
14. (137) Josh Fields 3B,OF
15. (144) Alex Gordon 1B,3B
16. (157) Jhonny Peralta SS
17. (164) Michael Bourn OF
18. (177) J.R. Towles C
19. (184) Brian Wilson RP
20. (197) Bill Hall OF
21. (204) Chris Duncan 1B,OF
22. (217) Jonathan Broxton RP
23. (224) Mike Napoli C
24. (237) Felipe López 2B,SS
25. (244) Randy Johnson SP
26. (257) Casey Kotchman 1B
27. (264) Jacque Jones OF
28. (277) Pat Neshek RP
29. (284) Jon Rauch RP
30. (297) Matt Diaz OF

free ballers
1. (9) Jimmy Rollins
2. (12) Ryan Howard
3. (29) Lance Berkman
4. (32) Russell Martin
5. (49) Garrett Atkins
6. (52) Dan Haren
7. (69) Aaron Harang
8. (72) Chipper Jones
9. (89) Adrián González
10. (92) Dan Uggla
11. (109) Nick Swisher
12. (112) Huston Street
13. (129) Rich Hill
14. (132) Pat Burrell
15. (149) John Maine
16. (152) Ken Griffey Jr.
17. (169) Chien-Ming Wang
18. (172) Joakim Soria
19. (189) Jeremy Hermida
20. (192) Andy Pettitte
21. (209) Kazuo Matsui
22. (212) Bengie Molina
23. (229) Barry Zito
24. (232) Scott Baker
25. (249) Gil Meche
26. (252) Joey Votto
27. (269) Jason Bartlett
28. (272) Kerry Wood
29. (289) George Sherrill
30. (292) Melvin Mora

Who has the better team, please let me know, WHIR.

who has better pitching, better hitting, and who is better overall.

Thanks

[jlm53089]

Forgot to say, it is a 5X5 ROTO, 10 team league
with 2 Catchers 1B 2B 3B SS 4 OF 2U 4SP 2RP 4P and the rest bench

[jlm53089]

Come on can I get some help here please.

[RedsChuck]

Team 1 spurned hitting in favor of pitching way to heavily in the top half of the draft.
Team 2 on the other hand, didn't bite too early on pitching, yet still put together a nice rotation.
Just looking at these 2 teams, i believe team 2 stands a better chance at winning the league; team 1 will probably be a middle of the pack team in a 10 team scenario.

[jlm53089]

anybody else?

[msbyanks02]

i agree with the guy above me.
Team 1 has top SP while team team has good SP, but in reality, pitching is so close that it does not make too much of a difference. But team 2 is very solid in all hitting categories while team 1 lacks some.

I'd appreciate some help with mine:
viewtopic.php?t=324353