Snakes Gould wrote:i have huge disagreements in your top 20 even and thats pretty hard to accomplish.
Alex Rodriguez- Best player
Hanley Ramirez- Best SS
David Wright- Next best (healthy) corner IF
Jose Reyes- Best SB guy/ Top SS
Matt Holliday- Best OF
Chase Utley- Would have been MVP if he hadn't missed 20 games last season
Jimmy Rollins- Was MVP as a result ^
Albert Pujols- Tough to drop him this far, but injury concern is legit
Miguel Cabrera- I could see Miguel being a little higher, but I'm worried about him breaking down a bit due to his weight
Johan Santana- Best pitcher just switched over to a weaker league
Ryan Howard- Potential 50 Home run guys are not in high supply
Carl Crawford- Potential 50 SB guys are not in high suppply
Jake Peavy- This might be a bit high for Peavy, but I feel once you get past him, securing an bona fide ace is pretty tough
Prince Fielder- See Ryan Howard
Ryan Braun- Amazing '07 season- sophmore slump concerns?
David Ortiz- Power seems to have peaked- RBI's probably have not
Lance Berkman- Stud 1B due for a bounce-back year
Brandon Phillips- Huge drop off at 2B after Phillips and Upton
Erik Bedard- Great K pitcher gets dealt to a good team from a bad team- now he should be a great W & K contributer
B.J. Upton- Would love to see another spike in terms of overall stats- he's so young, that I wouldn't bet against it...
So where are the HUGE disagreements? I have too many pitchers overvalued? I have 3 legit ACES in my top 20- that means there are 17 offensive players to go with them. Seems like a pretty fair split to me.
Last edited by SteveJeltzPhanClub on Tue Feb 26, 2008 6:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.