I bought the Show for my PS2 two weeks ago....I have a PS3 but am currently in Afghanistan and wasnt dragging it out here. I also haven't bought a baseball game since MVP '05....EA really screwed up losing that license.
Anyway, its a pretty different game, but as close to MVP as anything Ive played since. There are a few bugs that need to get worked out....hopefully by next year's version we'll have another great baseball video game.
Too may wild pitches
Outfield fielding(balls going right through guys), infield is not bad
Commentary/Music (I just mute it and put music on anyways)
Batting, power is a little difficult, but realistic
Dynasty/Road to the Show mode
Graphics (for PS2)
Its good enough to get me really pissed off and really excited at the same time.