i have to say that baseball stars pretty much made me into the stat freak that i am today. i used to play baseball mogul and baseball pro 98 back in college, and then for a long time HH01 for the PC was it for me. i've kinda struggled to find a game that i really enjoyed playing since then, but i must say that the show 07 for ps2 was as much fun i'd had playing a baseball game since sosa hh. but i gave my ps2 and games to my buddy as an early wedding present after i got my 360, so i had to go out and get mlb 2k8 yesterday. i played one game and stopped because it was all choppy and the controls were overbearing. i'm enjoying forza 2, call of duty 4, and college hoops 2k8 enough that it may be hard to play this game much if the controls dont become more intuitive sooner than later. i don't have plans to get a ps3, so i'm out of the running for the show. one other potential options -- mvp 05 was a good game and i used the 06 conversion mod from
MVPmods.com and it was great. looks like they are working on 08 as we speak, i may have to go pick up another copy of that game