Please grade this draft

[ssjl]

5x5 6th pick please grade6-10 with comments

c-salty
c-towles
1b-berkman
2b-kinsler
ss-ramirez
3b-lowell
of-markakis
of-dunn
of-pence
of-victorino
of-fields
u-kendrick
u-longoria
p-peavy
p-webb
p-billingsley
p-buchholz
p-gallardo
p-capps
p-chamberlain
p-c cordero
p-wagner

[ssjl]

thanks

[diehardsoxfan1008]

I would give it an 8. There is no point in having 2 catchers. I would get rid of Towles, Everything looks good except your outfield gets a bit shaky. If you stay like this you are going to have to rely on Markakis and I personnally think he is going to have troubles living up to expectations this year. I would try to trade for another solid out fielder but not bad.

[htmt519]

I agree with the other guy. Outfield is suspect. Drop the second catcher and pick up an OF (who's available?). Joba Chamberlain is a risk. Depending on the type of league you are in, keep an eye on closers - some of these roto leagues require 3 closers nowadays.

[ssjl]

2 catchers are mandatory

[chillyumpop]

i really like your team. you have a nice balance. if you have to have two catchers, then i think you should just check to make sure longoria makes the team as the starting 3rd baseman. otherwise he can be expendable for another OF. you should def keep chamberlain cuz even though he may not start he has great stats in mr and can help keep your era and whip down in h2h.