4 teams, 1 winner YOU CHOOSE

[buckfoston07]

This is a 5x5 14 team H2H League
These are 4 of the 14 teams in the league and we honestly want to know the best from a source outside of the league, completely impartial. RANK THE TEAMS FROM BEST TO WORST.
Will help in return, as always.

Team 1
C- Soto
1B- Ortiz
2B- Kendrick
3B- Atkins
SS- Rollins
OF- Hart
OF- Matsui
OF- Griffey Jr.
UTL- Fields

SP- Webb
SP- Lincecum
RP- Gregg
RP- Percival
P- Sherrill
P- Lyon
P- Howry
BN- McGowan
BN- Lilly
BN- Buchholz
BN- Maddux
BN- W. Rodriguez

Team 2
C-Towles
1b-Howard
2b-Roberts
3b-Braun
SS-O.Cabrera
Of-Abreu
Of-Hawpe
Of-Dye
UTIL-Burrell

SP-Kazmir
SP-Young
RP-Valverde
RP-Corpas
P-Maine
P-Arroyo
P-B.Wilson
BN-Garland
BN-Buehrle
BN-Gaudin
BN-Litsch

Team 3
C-Saltalamacchia
1b- Teixeira
2b- Weeks
3b- Aramis Ramirez
SS- Lugo
OF-Soriano
OF-Markakis
OF-Victorino
Util- Chipper Jones

SP- Burnett
SP- Vazquez
RP- Francisco Cordero
RP- Todd Jones
P- Tony Pena
P- Snell
P- Schilling
Bn- Ervin Santana
Bn- Glavine
Bn- Guthrie
Bn- Dempster
Bn- Mussina

Team 4
C - Molina
1B - Fielder
2B - Polanco
SS - Tulowitzki
3B - Zimmerman
OF - Sizemore
OF - CB Young
OF - Damon
Ut - Votto/Matthews

SP - Sabathia
SP - King Felix
SP - Liriano
SP - Wang
SP - Kuroda
SP - Shawn Hill
SP - Duscherer
RP - Lidge
RP - Gagne
RP - Betancourt

[hec1791]

its tough i would pick 1 or 4 as the best
1/4
2
3

[Some Guy 15]

I like team 1 for hitting but team 4 has better pitching imho.

close between the two.

Thanks for the reply

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=323231

[diehardsoxfan1008]

1 has really nice hitting but its pitching is kind of rough. Number 4 has really nice pitching and hitting for 14 teams. Overall I would say number 4.

[oakscorps]

1st) #4
2nd) #1 (close)
3rd) #2
4th) #3

[Shaffe]

4, 3, 1, 2 i'd say. it's kind of hard to take in 4 team's worth of rosters but 4 has good hitting and good pitching as well. i like 3 myself, i think that salty, tiexira, weeks, aramis, and soriano can really carry a team among 13 others. the pitching is what really held it back from 4 though. 1 is good like everybody else has said but i think the hitting outside of ortiz and rollins leaves a bit to be desired, the pitching past webb is a little weak as well. 2 just doesn't have many standouts besides kazmir and howard, it would be tough to have just those two carry a team without some of the other guys stepping up.

of course things could defiantly change as guys step up and regress, but that's how i see it for now.

[usclerkguy]

4-great pitching, good offense
1- great offense, good pitching
2- good offense, good pitching
3- good offense, average pitching



viewtopic.php?t=323549

[russellcv]

how can you say #4 has great pitching when their closers are lidge and gagne? good pitching at best.

kazmir, youg,and maine of team 2 compare with #4's top 3, aaaand team 2 has better closers.

i like teams 1 and 2 all around.

i dont like team 3's pitching too much. their offense is good enough.

team 4 is nice but void of closers.

ill say team 1 2 will win. all the teams are fairly close really.

[buckfoston07]

Think about the save opportunities Lidge/Gagne will get over Corpas/Valverde (with the left field porch in Houston).