12 Team 5x5 Keeper. How does it look? WHIR

[vtigers23]

We keep 10 players. Regular categories. How have I done?

C- Bengie Molina, C, SF Round 21 Pick 224
1B- Albert Pujols, 1B, STL Round 1 Pick 4
2B- Howie Kendrick, 2B, ANA Round 10 Pick 117
SS- Derek Jeter, SS, NNY Round 5 Pick 52
3B- Ryan Zimmerman, 3B, WAS Round 8 Pick 93
OF- Alfonso Soriano, OF, CHC Round 2 Pick 21
OF- Carlos Beltran, OF, NYM Round 3 Pick 28
OF- Willy Taveras, OF, COL Round 18 Pick 213
UTL- Travis Hafner, 1B-DH, CLE Round 4 Pick 45
UTL- Edwin Encarnacion, 3B, CIN Round 12 Pick 141 Reached a little

SP- Carlos Zambrano, SP, CHC Round 6 Pick 69
SP- Tim Lincecum, SP, SF Round 7 Pick 76
SP- Ben Sheets, SP, MIL Round 9 Pick 100
RP- Kevin Gregg, RP, FLA Round 14 Pick 165
RP- BJ Ryan, RP, TOR Round 15 Pick 172
P- Troy Percival, RP, TB Round 17 Pick 196
P- Chris Perez, RP, STL Round 16 Pick 189 Reached a little

BN- Jered Weaver, SP, ANA Round 13 Pick 148
BN- Bret Myers, SP, PHI Round 11 Pick 124
BN- Lastings Millege, OF, WAS Round 20 Pick 237
BN- Kevin Slowey, SP, MIN Round 19 Pick 220
BN- Scott Baker, SP, MIN Round 22 Pick 261
BN- Troy Glaus, 3B-SS, STL Round 23 Pick 268
BN- Carlos Ruiz, C, PHI Round 24 Pick 285
BN- Ty Wigginton, 1B-2B-3B, HOU Round 25 Pick 292
BN- Andre Ethier, OF, LAD Round 26 Pick 309

[Joshiroth]

Great Offense especially in the OF, I think you could do a little better on the pitching but its not that bad, as long a BJ can stay healthy you have a great team. My only suggestion would be to maybe try and pick up a nice pitcher, I'd say try to package one of your mid-level offensive players and a half decent pitcher and try to pick up a stud pitcher.

[TAa12fam]

I really like the offense in that you have a lot of runs, SBs, HRs, and RBIs.

Im a little skeptical of your staff with Zambrano at the top, but I do love the fact that Sheets in your #3. I feel he will be huge this year. Of course, Saves is a weird stat, so I assume you plan on picking up more closers during the year.

Nice team, i say 7/10

[TAa12fam]

Help with mine?

viewtopic.php?t=322471

[vtigers23]

bump

[Smipims]

Love your OF. I would like to know the round you drafted your players in and what pick you had. I sort of like the Pujols pick. He'll be a good keeper but I question his value until he heals up.

Don't really like Jeter. Think he's overrated.

Pitching staff is kinda weak I think and you don't have a very deep bench for your hitters.

Capable of winning this year? I don't think so. Capable of winning a few years down the road? ehhhh maybe with some good trades and the development of guys like Lincecum.

[vtigers23]

Updated with rounds and pick numbers. I actually really like this team, I think I reached on two players which I wrote that by in the original post. Other than that I am very happy with the team. How about some more opinions please?

[Smipims]

Players who I think you reached on:

Pujols (too risky right now with his injury imo. He could have another great year, but I've seen him fall to like 7th overall).

Lincecum (about 2-3 rounds too early imo)

Sheets (way early. about 5 rounds early)

Probably more, but I gtg right now.