Pick a Side In This Trade

[mm92280]

just want some opinions:

Team A gets: Chipper Jones, Boone, Randy Wolfe

Team B gets: Jeff Cirillo, Marlon Anderson, Javier Vasquez


thanks.

[Arlo]

5x5 roto, with all players starting for their teams and Chipper 3b-eligible?

Wolf is the kicker here. If he pitches as he did in his last outing, team A makes out like a bandit. If not, it's tight.

If I'm A, I make the deal if my pitching is good (top third of the league or so) and the league isn't overly deep.

If I'm B, I do this if I have some sort of backup plan at 2b, either on my bench or on waivers.

If you want the short answer, I'd give a very small edge to team A, factoring in the risk of adding Wolf. I'm far from certain about this, though.