For a keeper league, I'd probably go:
However, for redraft, I'll take Ortiz over both of them. Even with a "down" year last season, I say he arguably had the best one out of all three considering his .332 average. He only hit 35 bombs to Fielder's 50, but had more runs, similar RBIs, and hit 44 points higher. Give me a healthy Ortiz over any of the other two.