Sheff / Sosa / Ramirez / Ordonez

[Guest]

Ramirez (great all around, and good BA)
Sosa (could be the top power hitter in MLB)
Sheff (durablility questions)
Ordonez (doesn't run anymore

Sheffield .325-35-100-15
Manny .330-40-100-0
Maggs .325-35-120-10
Sosa .275-45-100-0

Those RBI projections look off the mark to me. You've got Maggs with the equal least number of homers but by far the most RBI's in the weakest batting lineup!! Avg's look about right and HR's but I would have Maggs with only 30.

For me it's
Sheffield
Manny
Sosa and Maggs even

[zEli173]

I've got it:

Shef and Manny (too close to call)
Mags
Sosa

[Transmogrifier]

Manny
Sheff
Mags
Sosa

This is how I have it.

[DJUmperPSU]

Shef is the man to take considering hes a yank SOOO

Shef
Manny
Sosa
Mags

[Pirate of the Carib]

Shef
Manny
Sosa
Mags

this ranking looks the best to me

[DJUmperPSU]

I think so, thanks for agreement

[djacks]

Ramirez (great all around, and good BA)
Sosa (could be the top power hitter in MLB)
Sheff (durablility questions)
Ordonez (doesn't run anymore

Sheffield .325-35-100-15
Manny .330-40-100-0
Maggs .325-35-120-10
Sosa .275-45-100-0

These numbers seem pretty close, however, I think Sheffield's avg and SB's are a little high...more like .305 and 8...not a huge difference, but I don't see him doing as well this year and he definetly won't run as much.

I'd rank them:

Manny
Sheff
Maggs
Sosa

[Mr.Cocky!]

Better take Maggs off of the list, C.Lee is the new top OF for the Sox.

[GSes]

Sheff
Mags
Manny
Sosa

[Trot Nixon]

WHAT ABOUT TROT NIXON!!!!!!!!