Sheff / Sosa / Ramirez / Ordonez

[ferris182]

How are these guys ranked?

I have:

Ramirez (great all around, and good BA)
Sosa (could be the top power hitter in MLB)
Sheff (durablility questions)
Ordonez (doesn't run anymore)

[trevisc]

Ramirez (great all around, and good BA)
Sosa (could be the top power hitter in MLB)
Sheff (durablility questions)
Ordonez (doesn't run anymore

Sheffield .325-35-100-15
Manny .330-40-100-0
Maggs .325-35-120-10
Sosa .275-45-100-0

[KolbSaves]

sheff
man ram
mags
"iss so real" sosa

[ironman]

Ramirez (great all around, and good BA)
Sosa (could be the top power hitter in MLB)
Sheff (durablility questions)
Ordonez (doesn't run anymore

Sheffield .325-35-100-15
Manny .330-40-100-0
Maggs .325-35-120-10
Sosa .275-45-100-0

What he said.

[Sox FANatic001]

sheff, mags, manny, sosa

[Nomar4prez]

Sosa(he's motivated to prove himself after shaming himself and his country)
Manny(Doesn't show any emotion, but gets the job done)
Sheff(That lineup is INCREDIBLE!)
Mags(Had a down year last year, but will bounce back)

[sigtaulefty]

Shef, Manny, Mags, Sosa

[Erboes]

Shef, Manny, Mags, Sosa

This is a good list if Sheffield and Manny both get 550 AB's. The safer bet though is Ordonez. For reasons stated many times here at the Cafe, not only will Sosa not even be close to these other guys, he won't even be in the top 100 players in $ value at the end of the season. Bad pick, that Sosa. Bad.

[DK]

Sheffield .325-35-100-15
Manny .330-40-100-0
Maggs .325-35-120-10
Sosa .275-45-100-0

By this list, do you mean that Manny will be more productive than Maggs by listing Manny second? Because by those #'s, I think I'd rather have Maggs.

[paulpett]

Manny
Sheff
Mags
Sosa